Why Google Assistant will beat Siri, Alexa and Cortana

移动互联 2018-05-05

Apple’s Siri virtual assistant is the best-known out there. Amazon dominates the home virtual-assistant appliance market with its Echo line.

But the early leaders rarely end up the market winners. Just a dozen years ago, the dominant mobile phone makers were Nokia and BlackBerry, and tech pundits were certain they’d be clobbered by Palm. Apple didn’t have a phone. Most mobile phone users had never heard of Android.

There’s no reason to believe that today’s virtual-assistant leaders will hold their lead.

The future of the virtual assistant is not where Apple dominates (on mobile phones) or where Amazon does (on home appliances). The space will be characterized by total ubiquity, which means wearables, all electronic devices, many IoT devices and embedded into all the places where humans spend time (offices, cars and homes).

Virtual assistants will become core enterprise tools and will be the main way humans are enhanced through artificial intelligence (A.I.).

I predicted in this space three and a half years ago that virtual-assistant appliances
would become ubiquitous in homes, and last year that they would make inroads into the enterprise

My newest prediction is that Google will win it all, becoming as dominant in virtual-assistant usage in the coming years as Facebook is dominant today in social, or as Apple in smartphone profits.

Here’s why I’m predicting that.

Google just hit the gas

Google I/O starts Tuesday, and the developer’s conference will be accompanied by lots of news, including announcements about new features for Google Assistant.

Google recently announced impressive penetration into third-party hardware. Specifically, in four months, it tripled the number of hardware devices that use Assistant
— from January to now, they rose from 1,500 devices to 5,000. (Amazon still dominates, with 12,000 devices.)

Google launched Assistant globally this year and promises to expand from eight languages to “more than 30” by the end of the year

Lots of people love Google Assistant. Literally! When Google launched the Google Home device in India last month, Google executive Rishi Chandra said that some 450,000 Indians had proposed marriage to Google Assistant

One reason for all that love is that Google Assistant is better, according to one report. A study published this week by the digital marketing firm Stone Temple found that Google Assistant is more accurate than Amazon’s Alexa, Siri or Microsoft’s Cortana
. (Siri was found to be least accurate.)

Google Assistant is arguably the most transparent, which engenders trust. Google makes it easy to delete records of individual Assistant interactions, or all of them

Google claims that Assistant can perform more than a million “actions.”
But that’s about to multiply enormously. Google has been building a developer program
to encourage and help developers build apps for Assistant.

This week the company announced a new program that includes investment in startups that build Google Assistant apps. The company also promised mentorship, advice and promotional support, as well as access to new features, tools and the Google Cloud Platform.

Google is specifically interested in app developers creating apps and content for vertical industries

The new initiative bolsters resources Google has previously offered
to foster development, including an inexpensive Voice Kit

In fact, Google Assistant is so important to Google that the company actually built two special Google Assistant buttons into its most important hardware products. The Google Pixelbook laptop has a dedicated key on the keyboard for conjuring up the Assistant. And the Pixelbook Pen stylus, which is sold separately from the Pixelbook, has a single button that, when pressed, queries the Assistant on whatever is circled with the Pen.

Of course, Google Assistant is already being used informally or unofficially by millions of people in businesses and enterprises
. But I believe the new investment initiative will encourage a massive new push into the enterprise.

But here’s the real reason Google Assistant will prevail

Google is the only major virtual-assistant company with the right mission and culture to succeed in this space.

To wit:

Amazon just wants to sell you stuff; the public doesn’t see Amazon as an information source. Amazon won’t give you the best price on something if that something isn’t for sale on Amazon.

Microsoft doesn’t have a foothold of any significance in mobile or in virtual-assistant appliances.

Apple has no interest in serving people who don’t buy Apple hardware. So Apple won’t even try to reach everybody with Siri.

Meanwhile, Google is at its core a search engine company. Because virtual assistants will largely supplant search engines, Google Assistant must predominate in order for Google to continuing being Google. Google Voice Search is being completely replaced by Google Assistant

Apple’s advantage was that it started early with the acquisition of Siri eight years ago. Amazon’s advantage was the prescient release of the Amazon Echo appliance three years ago.

But as the competition heats up, it turns out Google has most of the advantages needed to win.

For starters, Google’s Android is the world’s most widely used operating system, and its Play Store has by far the most apps. That translates to far more developers familiar with Google’s development tools and processes, which will eventually translate into far more apps for the Assistant.

Second, the quality of A.I. will increasingly become a deciding factor, and on this score Google is way ahead of Amazon. Already, Google Assistant is being improved on Wear OS (formerly Android Wear) with a new feature called smart suggestions, enabling users to dig deeper into their Assistant queries by simply choosing one of the contextually relevant follow-up options it presents. Behind the scenes, Google’s superior A.I. will reduce errors, increase predictive interaction and generally make Assistant more satisfying and powerful to use than the competition.

Third, Google has more user data, which improves personalization and agency as those very qualities become more central to the virtual-assistant experience. Beyond Search and other services, Google has access to data in your Gmail account, if you use Gmail, which is a gold mine of actionable user data for a personal assistant.

Fourth, as Whitney Houston used to sing, the children are our future. And children are increasingly getting Chromebooks in schools. Between 2012 and 2017, Google’s share of the mobile K-12 education market rocketed from 5.2% to 59%
, very much at the expense of Apple and Microsoft. This dominance is taking place at a time when Google Assistant is becoming increasingly integrated with, and central to, the Chromebook experience.

In other words, most high school grads from now on will be intimately familiar with Google Assistant.

In short, Google has far more people using its platforms, has better A.I. and has stronger motivation to win.

Bet on Google Assistant to dominate the coming world of virtual assistants.


谷歌进军印度移动支付市场,将于下周推出本地化数字支付服务“Tez”... 【猎云网(微信号:)】9月14日报道 (编译:拿铁小心心) 外媒消息,谷歌计划在印度推出一款本地化数字支付服务,最快下周上线。 据悉,这一服务名叫“Tez”(在印度表示快的意思),将提供全面的支付功能,超过谷歌钱包或安卓支付。比方说,Tez支持印度政府的统一支付界面(Unified...
谷歌翻译又被专业翻译diss了:那它到底有没有用?... 新浪科技 姜轶群 春节假期已经过去几天了,不知道大家有没有吃好玩好?朋友圈这几天几乎被美食、萌娃视频和景点照片刷屏了,让人好生羡慕。 朋友圈(为保护隐私,一些信息打了码) 不知道大家注意到没有,上面四条朋友圈消息,有一条是在俄罗斯发出来的。实际上,在这个传统上要回乡团聚的日子里,...
谷歌在印度推出个性化内容服务:Google Feed... 据印媒《经济时报》消息, 互联网巨头谷歌公司为了在印度获得更多的用户不惜煞费苦心,他们正在印度筹备推出一项个性化内容服务——Google Feed,同时还会推出一款智能扬声器和Google Home 智能助手服务。 一位谷歌公司高管证实了这个消息,他声称,谷歌将会很快在印度推出Google ...
传谷歌助手可设置为iPhone默认语音助手... 智能语音助手领域的竞争如今愈发激烈,各大科技巨头都推出了自己的智能语音助手,如苹果的Siri、微软的Cortana、亚马逊的Alexa以及谷歌的Google Assistant。这些语音智能助手通常会在自家的产品中扎根并利用这一平台发展壮大。 日前据Androidguys报道称,苹果正在和...
从产品视角看智能客服 本文缘起来自咱们饭团“AI产品经理大本营”团员Wilde_lin的提问:“请问团长, 智能客服,会是一个好方向吗? 希望能从 技术的发展应用,行业深度 以及作为 PM的发展前景 几个角度聊一聊”,本文分享一点产品视角的浅见,抛砖引玉;感兴趣的朋友,欢迎在评论区讨论交流。 智能...