Gogo’ ‘Grossly Overpriced,’ Given Competition, Says Northland

科技动态 2017-09-20 阅读原文

Shares of in-flight Wifi provider Gogo
(GOGO) are down 97 cents or almost 7%, at $13.23, after Northland Capital Markets
’s Paul Penney
today initiated coverage of the stock with an Underperform rating, and a $6.75 price target, writing that fierce competition
will delay its ability to become profitable, and will strain its balance sheet.

And discount airlines
, its next opportunity, don’t hold much promise, he thinks.

As a result, "we believe GOGO’s shares are excessively overpriced
on both an absolute and relative basis,” writes Penney, referring to a multiple of 18.8 times his Ebitda projection
for next year, compared to valuations for peers of 6.7 times.

“We believe a more rational valuation
level to be $6.75/share
, which equates to 11.25X our 2018 EBITDA estimate of $92.3M."

Penney writes that what “sparked our apprehensions” are estimates calling for an 86% or create jump in Ebitda next year, to $113 million, after a decline of 9% last year, in a "hyper-competitive” market for airplane WiFi.

There are six or seven competitors
in any given market, notes Penney, and “as we looked closer at both Gogo’s domestic and international market share positioning, we believe there is an increasing level of vulnerability driven by a blend of evolving airline customer dynamics, increasing commoditization and technology related deficiencies."

On the domestic (US) side, GOGO is the clear market share leader today with ~66% of the total market (equating to ~2,791 total connected planes) and represents ~59% of total revenues. However, we believe there are clear signs of risk in GOGO’s dominance today, as the airlines proactively move away from having a sole connectivity provider to a “multi-sourced” model. In the end, the airlines motivations for moving to a more diversified service provider model could be driven by a variety of different factors: 1) Lower costs, 2) Improve technology related offerings, 3) Broaden bandwidth capacity and/ or 4) Drive faster implementation timing.

Already, American Airlines
and Alaska Air have been swapping out Gogo, he writes:

In fact, these “clear signs of risk” have been clearly tangible and more frequent of late; as two of GOGO’s sizable US customers (American Airlines and Alaska Airlines) have either undisputedly moved or threatened to move their IFC business from GOGO to a competing IFC provider […] At the time, an American spokesperson clearly articulated their desire to multi-source so they could “upgrade our fleet with the latest and fastest Wi-Fi service as quickly as possible”. More recently in August 2017, GOGO’s long-term customer Alaska Air put out a competitive RFP (Request For Proposal) that ultimately concluded in a re-newel agreement with GOGO. While many investors and bullish analysts misperceived this announcement as a “new customer win” for GOGO, we believe it not only clearly demonstrates the airlines desire to aggressively look to reduce costs / enhance their quality of service, but likely resulted in a reduced contractual rate.

Bulls, he writes, would like to believe there are "4 domestic airlines that are potential new GOGO connectivity customers
,” but he thinks that’s wishful thinking, especially given the four most likely, including Spirit Airlines
, are “ultra-low cost carriers,” the discounters.

They “charge for everything and anything they can,” including water, coffee and soda, Penney observes.

“We believe the likelihood of one of these airlines investing in IFC or having their customer base pay much of anything for the service greatly tempers our enthusiasm for any meaningful level of incremental revs / EBITDA contributions."

The “ field of dreams
” nature of this business will continue to drive costs up for Gogo, he opines:

The long term bull case on GOGO rests on the old adage from the 1989 baseball movie classic Field of Dreams – “If you build it, they will come”, as GOGO’s near term high / accelerating levels of CAPEX and OPEX will soon dissipate with an eventual boost in revenues / EBITDA on the other side. We believe this long term theory is far reaching and flawed, as new connected aircraft installation and ongoing IFC service costs will remain stubbornly high for GOGO.

Tech Trader Daily

责编内容by:Tech Trader Daily阅读原文】。感谢您的支持!


中国最大无人码头年底开港 每年吞吐400万标准箱... 参考消息网8月15日报道港媒称,全球最大的集装箱自动化码头“上海国际航运中心洋山深水港区四期工程”,目前已进入设备安装和调试阶段,计划在2017年12月10日开港试运营。其设计吞吐能力初期达到一年400万标准箱,远期将达到一年630万标准箱,可满足多艘大型集装箱船同时靠泊。 据《香港经济日报》...
为了扭亏,Sprint任命资深转型战略家科贝斯为总裁... 腾讯科技讯 据外媒报道,美国移动营运商Sprint周四宣布,公司已经任命资深转型战略家米歇尔-科贝斯(Michel Combes)为总裁兼首席财务官,此举是为了提高公司盈利能力以实现扭亏目标。 该公司在声明中表示,科贝斯将于1月6日就任,现任首席财务官塔雷克-罗比亚蒂(Tarek Robb...
丰田马自达建合资新公司 日系新能源会迎第二春... 坐不住的日本人终于下定决心,丰田前日宣布,将和马自达、日本电装(Denso)合资成立一家新公司,专门开发电动车技术。新公司定名EV Common Architecture Spirit。 一个多月前,丰田收购马自达5% 股份,并宣布二者将在美国成立合资公司,共同在美投资16亿美元建厂,研发...
麦肯锡:关于科技巨头的超额回报,你需要知道这些... 雷锋网:高科技(Technology)、媒体(Media)和电信(Telegcom),这三种行业组成了我们经常听到的TMT行业。作为这个行业的最明显特征,就是丰厚的回报。当然,很多人并不知道这些企业的超额回报是如何实现的,更不知道它们与自己有何关系。 近日, 麦肯锡 新发布了一份调查结果,其中...
7 Keys To Building Good Habits And Happiness At Wo... Are you one of those people who believe that happiness at work is an oxymoron? If so, maybe it’s time to rethink your perspective, and perhaps start...