Probably the number one complaint I hear from Hypothesis users is that it “doesn’t work” with py.test fixtures.This isn’t true, but it does have one very specific limitation in how it works that annoys people: It only runs function scoped fixtures once for the entire test, not once per example. Because of the way people use function scoped fixtures for handling stateful things like databases, this often causes people problems.
I’ve been maintaining for a whilethat this is impossible to fix without some changes on the pytest end.
The good news is that this turns out not to be the case. After some conversations with pytest developers, some examining of other pytest plugins, and a bunch of prototyping, I’m pretty sure it’s possible. It’s just really annoying and a lot of work.
So that’s the good news. The bad news is that this isn’t going to happen without someone funding the work.
I’ve now spent about a week of fairly solid work on this, and what I’ve got is quite promising: The core objective of running pytest fixtures for every examples works fairly seamlessly.
But it’s now in the long tail of problems that will need to be squashed before this counts as an actual production ready releasable piece of work. A number of things don’twork. For example, currently it’s running some module scoped fixtures once per example too, which it clearly shouldn’t be doing. It also currently has some pretty major performance problems that are bad enough that I would consider them release blocking.
As a result I’d estimate there’s easily another 2-3 weeks of work needed to get this out the door.
Which brings us to the crux of the matter: 2-3 additional weeks of free work on top of the one I’ve already done is 3-4 weeks more free work than I particularly want to do on this feature, so without sponsorship it’s not getting finished.
I typically charge £400/day for work on Hypothesis (this is heavily discounted off my normal rates), so 2-3 weeks comes to £4000 to £6000 (roughly $5000 to $8000) that has to come from somewhere.
I know there are a number of companies out there using pytest and Hypothesis together. I know from the amount of complaining about this integration that this is a real problem you’re experiencing. So, I think this money should come from those companies. Besides helping to support a tool you’ve already got a lot of value out of, this will expand the scope of what you can easily test with Hypothesis a lot, and will be hugely beneficial to your bug finding efforts.
This is a model that has worked well before with the funding of the recent statistics work by Jean-Louis Fuchsand Adfinis-SyGroup, and I’m confident it can work well again.
If you work at such a company and would like to talk about funding some or part of this development, please email me at [email protected]